Home   News   Article

Ramblers Scotland slam closure of Ben Alder level crossing as 'unacceptable' and 'disrespectful'


By Gavin Musgrove

Register for free to read more of the latest local news. It's easy and will only take a moment.



Click here to sign up to our free newsletters!
The Ben Alder level-crossing provides access to the peak of the same name. Photo: Danny Carden
The Ben Alder level-crossing provides access to the peak of the same name. Photo: Danny Carden

Ramblers Scotland has said it is lobbying to get the Ben Alder level-crossing reopened as soon as possible.

The charity has waded into the controversy and is fully behind the community effort to reverse Network Rail's locking of the gates on the outskirts of Dalwhinnie.

The Ramblers have issued a fulsome statement condemning the rail body for breaching long-standing access rights and turning the railway into 'an impenetrable barrier for most people'.

They stated: "It is our understanding that less than a week’s notice was given to the local community, landowner or the Highland Council of their intention, and they did not inform representative recreation bodies in advance at all.

"This is unacceptable and high-handed behaviour by Network Rail which fails to reflect the wider public interest in the level crossing nor does it reflect Network Rail’s own pledge to work collaboratively and sensitively with communities living near the railway.

"The track from Dalwhinnie is a historic route leading to Rannoch Moor and linking with the Road to the Isles.

"The route pre-dates the coming of the railways and has been well used for decades by hillwalkers, cyclists and others heading to the Ben Alder area and beyond.

"Core paths lead up to the railway on either side, showing its regional importance for access. It also links to the local path network on the west of the railway line which has been developed by the local community.

"We recognise that walkers and others will continue to cross at this point by climbing over the gates thus presumably increasing any safety risk which Network Rail may have used internally to justify closing the crossing.

"There is an underpass some distance south of the crossing which may be a useful alternative for those with bikes, buggies or wheelchairs, or riding a horse, but we expect people will continue to use the crossing with care as they have always done, as this has always been a formal facility which enables people to cross the railway line at this location.

"Where access rights apply on land on either side of the railway, the Scottish Outdoor Access Code requires landowners, in this case Network Rail, to take account of such access rights and to facilitate any customary access that is needed to exercise those rights.

"We understand that vehicular access to the local estate will continue over the crossing so, if this can be achieved safely, it seems obvious to us that non-motorised should also continue for walkers, cyclists and everyone in the local community.

"The private use of motor vehicles by estate owners, employees and visitors provides access to a privileged few, turns the railway into an impenetrable barrier for most people in the nearby village and elsewhere and is contrary to the requirements of Scottish access legislation.

"This leads us to question the basis on which the crossing has been closed.

"We consider this closure to be disrespectful of the local community and wider public interest and to show a complete misunderstanding of the basis on which access is taken in Scotland.

We are working with other recreation bodies and are in contact with Dalwhinnie Community Council, the Cairngorms National Park Authority, Highland Council and the National Access Forum with a view to getting this level crossing reopened as soon as possible."

Anger in Dalwhinnie after Network Rail locks popular level-crossing


Do you want to respond to this article? If so, click here to submit your thoughts and they may be published in print.



This site uses cookies. By continuing to browse the site you are agreeing to our use of cookies - Learn More