Strathspey and Badenoch Herald
15 May, 2008
RSS
The Big Vote - and your views on the latest hot topic
OPINION » The Big Vote
Is an 11-storey building right for Aviemore?
Published:  21 April, 2008

No - My first visit to Aviemore was over 25 years ago and it was a concrete jungle that did not blend in with the surroundings. I avoid the village at all costs these days, even though I'm in the area quite a lot, as it is an eyesore with very little character. An 11-storey building would only make the place look worse and be a blot on the local landscape. These developers have no interest in the surroundings. They are only interested in capital gain. I thought lesson's would have been learned from the previous mistakes. Seems not. Mr Fraser, Aberdeen

Yes - The building is spectacular, has the wow factor, and will become an iconic piece of architecture, not only within the landscape of Aviemore, but the Highlands as a whole. S Palmer

No - People come to the area to look at the scenery and mountains, not to look at a tower block! The existing 7-storey building is an eyesore which does not fit in with the rest of the village and an 11-storey building would completely spoil the whole aspect. Janet Morse

No - Not in character with the village/area. Existing 6-storey hotel is already an eye-sore. The developer is only maximizing profit by using as little land coverage as possible, despite what they may claim. Why not build an old-style building similar to Cairngorm Hotel – I would support that idea? Do we really need more holiday homes in Aviemore? – supply and demand comes to mind – this could kill the demand and we should be providing more indoor activity facilities for all the visitors. Annie

No - I live in the area and speak to many visitors, and they come here for the Highlands, wildlife and outdoor activities; and they come here precisely because the area offers something different from our big cities. If they want a city environment and culture then that is where these people should head. Let's preserve the Highlands and provide the visitors with the special experience that we do. And of course most of us living here in the area chose to do so for the same reasons as people who visit. Highland Council must reject this proposal to protect both the environment and for the future of tourism. Christine Watkins, Baddengorm, Insh, by Kingussie

No - Aviemore is already an architectural embarrassment. An 11-storey development would merely add to the architectural melange. Nothing should be built that is higher than the highest existing building. People come here for the high mountains, the views, the great outdoors etc; they do not expect, or want, to see city-type developments. The number of visitors who express disappointment at the look and feel of Aviemore is very high as it is. This is not an anti-commercialism rant, rather a plea that any development should be in keeping with the overall environment. Rodger Redpath

Should parking charges be introduced at the Coire Cas car park?
Published:  14 April, 2008

Yes - Everyone who uses the facility should pay - not just the ones who ski or sightsee. Ed Guest

Should snaring be banned by the Scottish Government?
Published:  26 March, 2008

No - In many areas of Scotland, snaring is by far the most effective, and in many places the ONLY way to control foxes. Ian de Sales La Terriere

Are Bear and Transerv doing a good job this winter?
Published:  21 February, 2008

No – Anyone with even limited experience of European countries, which experience severe weather conditions much worse than ours, must realise how pathetic our response is by comparison to a bit of snow. And given the apparent reluctance to improve the A9 is it not reasonable for tax payers to expect what little road we do have to be properly cared for and backed up with the means to keep it clear! Alex Pagett

Should Aviemore businesses be compensated for loss of trade caused by summer redevelopment?
Published:  19 September, 2007

No - The business people will reap the benfits after the work is finished. Stan Livingston

Does it matter if Heatherbrae Hotel in Nethy Bridge becomes a house?
Published:  23 July, 2007

Yes - Having connections to Nethy Bridge since birth (my father was born there and we spent our summers there growing up), Heatherbrae has been in our lives for ever. It has to be the friendliest pub in Scotland! And is certainly much needed in this small tourist town. Please don't let it fall prey to the modern life! We need Heatherbrae in Nethy Bridge. Dorothy Black

Should the Beauly-Denny power line be allowed to cross Cairngorms National Park?
Published:  16 July, 2007

Not at all - Wind farms are an unreliable and destabilising source of electricity for the National Grid. In addition they are a blot on Scotland's wild land and do next to nothing for climate change. In fact because of the peat disruption and the electrical support required from gas turbine generators (to stabilise the grid), they actually contribute more to greenhouse gases than they save. Mary Stewart

Should wind farms be allowed near Cairngorms National Park?
Published:  12 February, 2007

No - Apart from being unsightly, heavy falls of snow cause faults with the supply of electricity. On this point alone I would support the lines being underground. Many years ago South Lanarkshire had a huge pipeline laid, coming from the oil fields and going on down to England. The countryside looked devastated at the time, but within a year or two everything was back to normal, and it is now impossible to see where the route was. The disruption and unsightliness was over within a few months, unlike these giant pylons, which will be with us for generations to come. Elizabeth Scott, South Lanarkshire

Does it matter if the Highland Folk Museum closes?
Published:  11 January, 2007

Yes - Should not close because it shows examples of our national heritage. A lot of work and thought has gone into this and it is extremely interesting for locals and tourists alike. Maria Rose Austin

  • Photos
  • AHR
  • 100 Years
THE BIG VOTE

Is an 11-storey building right for Aviemore?

  • Yes
  • No
  • Maybe
All content copyright 2008 Scottish Provincial Press Ltd.